The short answer: choose direct wholesale when you want an approved Rock Paper Scissors trade account and a direct relationship with us. Choose Faire when your store already prefers Faire's marketplace, account, and purchasing workflow. The artwork can overlap; the best path is the one your team can order, receive, reconcile, and reorder consistently.
Quick comparison
Decision
Direct wholesale
Faire
Account
Approved Rock Paper Scissors trade account
Your existing Faire buyer account
Shopping environment
Our protected trade portal
Faire marketplace
Assortment conversation
Useful when you want direct help selecting a focused assortment
Useful when your team centralizes marketplace purchasing
Terms and availability
Shown in the direct trade channel
Shown in Faire for your account
Reordering
Return to the direct portal and company account
Reorder through your Faire workflow
Choose direct wholesale when
You want a direct trade relationship with Rock Paper Scissors.
You want your approved company account, pricing, and ordering context in one portal.
You would benefit from help narrowing artwork for a specific store, museum, project, or display.
Your team is comfortable managing this vendor relationship outside a marketplace.
Direct access is review-gated. Start with the wholesale application; approved buyers receive access to the protected trade portal.
Choose Faire when
Your team already discovers and purchases brands through Faire.
You prefer to keep marketplace orders, messages, and account terms together.
Your receiving or bookkeeping process is already organized around Faire.
You want to compare this assortment alongside other Faire brands.
The ordering channel matters less than choosing a coherent assortment your staff can merchandise and replenish.
Compare current terms in the channel
Do not use an old invoice, screenshot, or blog post as the source of truth for current pricing, case quantities, availability, or terms. Those details can change and may differ by approved account or channel. Review them in the direct portal or Faire when you are preparing the order.
Can a retailer use both?
A business may have practical reasons to use more than one buying system, but duplicate purchasing creates receiving and reorder confusion. Choose a default channel for Rock Paper Scissors and record it in your vendor notes. If your process changes, switch deliberately rather than placing the same replenishment order twice.
Decision checklist
Which account does the buyer already use every week?
Where does accounting expect invoices and order history?
Does the store want direct assortment help?
Who owns reordering, and where will they look first?
Have you checked current terms in the chosen channel?
A practical first-order checklist for independent retailers: define the display, choose a focused mix, confirm current terms, plan receiving, and set a review date.